Democratic capitalism

Template:Short description Template:Capitalism sidebar Template:Democracy sidebar Template:Economic systems sidebar Democratic capitalism, also referred to as market democracy, is a political and economic system that integrates resource allocation by marginal productivity (synonymous with free-market capitalism), with policies of resource allocation by social entitlement.<ref name=":0">Template:Cite journal</ref> The policies which characterise the system are enacted by democratic governments.<ref name=":0"/>

Democratic capitalism was implemented widely in the 20th century, particularly in Europe and the Western world after the Second World War. The coexistence of capitalism and democracy, particularly in Europe, was supported by the creation of the modern welfare state in the post-war period.<ref name="Capitalism and Inequality, 2013">Muller, Jerry Z. (March 2013). "Capitalism and Inequality". Foreign Affairs.</ref> The implementation of democratic capitalism typically involves the enactment of policies expanding the welfare state, strengthening the collective bargaining rights of employees, or strengthening competition laws. These policies are enacted in a capitalist economy characterized by the right to private ownership of property.

Catholic social teaching offers support for a communitarian form of democratic capitalism with an emphasis on the preservation of human dignity.

The different definitions

Democratic capitalism is a type of political and economic system<ref>Template:Cite journal</ref> characterised by resource allocation according to both marginal productivity and social need, as determined by decisions reached through democratic politics.<ref name=":0" /> It is marked by democratic elections, freedom, and rule of law, characteristics typically associated with democracy.<ref name=":1">Template:Cite journal</ref><ref name=":7">Template:Cite book</ref> It retains a free-market economic system with an emphasis on private enterprise.<ref name=":1"/><ref name=":7"/>

Professor of Entrepreneurship Elias G. Carayannis and Arisitidis Kaloudis, Economics Professor at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), describe democratic capitalism as an economic system which combines robust competitiveness with sustainable entrepreneurship, with the aim of innovation and providing opportunities for economic prosperity to all citizens.<ref name=":2">Template:Cite journal</ref>

Edward Younkins, professor at Wheeling University, described democratic capitalism as a “dynamic complex of economic, political, moral-cultural, ideological, and institutional forces”, which serves to maximize social welfare within a free market economy.<ref name=":3">Template:Cite web</ref> Younkins states that the system of individual liberty inherent within democratic capitalism supports the creation of voluntary associations, such as labour unions.<ref name=":3"/>

Philosopher and writer Michael Novak characterised democratic capitalism as a blend of a free-market economy, a limited democratic government, and moral-cultural system with an emphasis on personal freedom.<ref name=":4">Template:Cite web</ref> Novak comments that capitalism is a necessary, but not a sufficient condition of democracy.<ref name=":4" /> He also proposes that the prominence of democratic capitalism in a society is strongly determined by the religious concepts which drive its customs, institutions, and leaders.<ref>Template:Cite journal</ref>

History

Early to mid-20th century

The development of democratic capitalism was influenced by several historical factors, including the rapid economic growth following World War One, the Great Depression, and the political and economic ramifications of World War Two.<ref name=":5">Template:Cite journal</ref><ref name=":8">Template:Cite book</ref> The growing critique of free-market capitalism and the rise of the notion of social justice in political debate contributed to the adoption of democratic capitalist policies.<ref name=":5"/>

At the Bretton Woods Conference of 1944, officials from the United States and the United Kingdom and forty-two other nations committed to trade openness.<ref name=":8" /> This commitment was made in conjunction with international guidelines which guaranteed autonomy for each country in responding to economic and social demands of its voters.<ref name=":8" /> Officials requested international capital controls which would allow governments to regulate their economies while remaining committed to the goals of full employment and economic growth.<ref name=":8"/> The adoption of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade supported free trade, while allowing national governments to retain veto power over trade policy.<ref name=":8"/> Such developments saw the incorporation of democratic demands into policies based on capitalist economic logic.<ref name=":8"/>

Democratic capitalism was first widely implemented after the Second World War in the Western world, particularly in North America and Western Europe.<ref name=":0"/> Following the severe economic impacts of the war, working classes in the Western world were more inclined to accept capitalist markets in conjunction with political democracy, which enabled a level of social security and improved living standards.<ref name=":0"/> In the post-war decades, democratic capitalist policies saw reduced levels of socioeconomic inequality.<ref name=":5"/> This was synonymous with the expansion of welfare states, more highly regulated financial and labour markets, and increased political power of labour unions.<ref name=":5"/> According to political scientist Wolfgang Merkel, democracy and capitalism coexisted with more complementarity at this time than at any other point in history.<ref name=":5"/>

Policy makers in Europe and Asia adopted democratic capitalist policies in an attempt to satisfy the social needs of their voters and respond to the challenge of communism.<ref name=":7"/> The policies implemented supported the public provision of medical care, improved public housing, aged care, and more accessible education.<ref name=":7"/> Guarantees of full employment and the support of private research and innovation became priorities of policy makers.<ref name=":7"/> Policy developments were based on the rising notion that free markets required some state intervention to maintain them, provide structure, and address social inequities caused by them.<ref name=":7"/> Governments around the world regulated existing markets in an attempt to increase their equity and effectiveness.<ref name=":7"/> In order to stabilise the business cycle, the role of government was reconceived by anticommunist leaders in Britain, France, Italy, Germany, Scandinavia, and Japan.<ref name=":7"/> An emphasis was placed on supporting economic growth, promoting innovation, and enhancing living standards.<ref name=":7"/> This saw the expansion of educational opportunities and public insurance of basic health and aged benefits.<ref name=":7"/>

United States

As automated production expanded in the United States, demand for semi skilled workers increased.<ref name=":8" /> Combined with the expansion of secondary education, this saw the development of a large working class.<ref name=":8"/> The resulting strong economic growth and improved income equality allowed for greater social peace and universal suffrage.<ref name=":8"/> Capitalism was viewed as a means of producing the wealth which maintained political freedom, while a democratic government ensured accountable political institutions and an educated labour force with its basic rights fulfilled.<ref name=":8"/>

Europe

In the postwar period, free market economic systems with political systems of democracy and welfare states were established in France and Germany.<ref name=":8"/> This occurred under the leadership of the Popular Republican Movement in France and the Christian Democratic Union in Germany.<ref name=":8"/>

Late 20th century

Following the oil shocks of the 1970s and the productivity slowdown in the United States in the 1980s, politicians and voters maintained strong support for democratic capitalist policies and free markets.<ref name=":8"/> Globalisation and free trade were promoted as a means of boosting economic growth, and this saw the formation of the North American Free Trade Agreement and the European Union.<ref name=":8"/> Labour market and competition regulations were eased in existing free-market economies, particularly in Anglo-America.<ref name=":8"/>

Rapid technological innovation and globalisation brought widespread international economic change.<ref name=":8"/> Publicly funded democratic capitalist policies were designed and implemented to compensate individuals negatively affected by major, structural economic change.<ref name=":8"/> Implemented beginning in the early years of the Cold War, such policies included unemployment benefits, universal or partially universal healthcare, and aged pensions.<ref name=":8"/> Post-1970s, the number of public sector jobs available expanded.<ref name=":8"/> Ageing populations in Europe, Japan and North America saw large increases in public spending on pensions and healthcare.<ref name=":8"/> In the 1980s, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development economies began reducing corporate taxation, though personal income taxes and public spending on social security programs generally remained stable.<ref name=":8"/>

Large-scale innovation in production technology throughout the 20th century had widespread economic benefits in many capitalist economies.<ref name=":8"/> These benefits contributed to the conciliation of democratic politics and free markets and the widespread acceptance of democratic capitalist policies by voters.<ref name=":8"/>

From the late 20th century, the tenets of democratic capitalism expanded more broadly beyond North America and Western Europe.<ref name=":9">Template:Cite journal</ref>

United States

After taking office as president in 1981, Ronald Reagan advocated for a reduced role of government in the economy, while responding to voters’ skepticism of liberal capitalism by maintaining strong public sector spending.<ref name=":7"/> Many voters doubted the ability of free market capitalism to provide consistent peace, security and opportunity, and sought improved living standards, aged care, and educational opportunities for youth.<ref name=":7"/> The Reagan administration maintained previous levels of government expenditure on Social Security and Medicare as a proportion of gross domestic product (GDP).<ref name=":7"/> Total government expenditure levels as a percentage of GDP also remained stable under the Reagan administration.<ref name=":7"/>

The anarcho capitalist Hans Hermann-Hoppe got quoted in the book "Against the Left- A Rothbardian Libertarianism, (Preface)" from Lew Rockwell, where Hoppe said followed: "The "neo-conservatives" a movement inspired and led by a group of former Trotskyite intellectuals, who proposed to combine a "Welfare-State" at home, also called "democratic capitalism," with US imperialism abroad and the drive toward world-domination."<ref>Against the Left- A Rothbardian Libertarianism, (Preface)" Lew Rockwell</ref>

Former US President George W. Bush said in the past:"Democratic capitalism is the greatest system ever conceived." He intended to describe the threat to capitalism linked to democracy both in his country and in most of the world, in the context of the dramatic speech (September 2008) in which he raised the need to save it from the financial crisis of 2008 , which he posed in very serious terms.<ref>http://www.elpais.com/articulo/panorama/modelo/tela/juicio/elpepusocdgm/20081005elpdmgpan_1/Tes/</ref>

Europe

From the mid-1980s, European leaders began endorsing neoliberal ideas, such as those associated with Reaganomics and Thatcherism, based on the notion of the interdependence of economic and social policy.<ref name=":9"/> In this context, European competition law policy developed as a method of curbing the excesses of capitalism, while aligning the economy of the European Union with the existing democratic ideals of European society.<ref name=":9"/> This saw the advancement of democratic capitalism throughout the European region.<ref name=":9"/>

South Africa

The South African Competition Act of 1998 prioritised the eradication of anticompetitive business practices and the free participation in the economy of all citizens, while maintaining a pro-free-market economy.<ref name=":1" />

Early 21st century

India

India enacted the Competition Act, 2002 to promote and sustain competition and protect the welfare of market participants, goals synonymous with democratic capitalism.<ref name=":1"/>

Implementation

The post-war implementation of democratic capitalism saw the expansion of welfare states and the free collective bargaining rights of employees, alongside market policies designed to ensure full employment.<ref name=":0"/>

Under democratic capitalism, an autonomous democratic state enacts of policies which in effect create a compromise between upper and lower classes, while remaining compatible with free-market capitalism.<ref name=":10">Template:Cite journal</ref> Such policies include the establishment or expansion of a welfare state, as a method of mediating social class conflict and catering to the demands of workers.<ref name=":10"/>

The system is characterised by the establishment of cooperative economic institutions.<ref name=":11">Template:Cite journal</ref> This includes institutions which facilitate bargaining between government bodies and business and labour organisations such as unions, and those which regulate the relationships between employees and management within private firms.<ref name=":11" /> The development of institutions to promote cooperation among public and private economic entities acknowledges the benefits of market competition, while attempting to address the social problems of unrestrained capitalism.<ref name=":11"/>

Economic security concerns of citizens are addressed through redistributive policies.<ref name=":11"/> Such policies include income transfers, such as welfare payment programs and pensions, to support the financial needs of the elderly and the poor.<ref name=":11"/> Other policies which promote economic security include social insurance, and the fiscal financing of education and job training programs to stimulate employment.<ref name=":11"/>

The right to private ownership of productive property is a central tenet of democratic capitalism, and is recognized as a basic liberty of all democratic citizens, as in a regular free-market capitalist economy.<ref name=":6">Template:Cite journal</ref> According to political philosopher John Tomasi, democratic capitalism addresses social entitlement and justice concerns through the preservation of citizens’ private property rights, allowing citizens to be “free, equal, and self-governing”.<ref name=":6"/>

The robust competitiveness and sustainable entrepreneurship which define democratic capitalism are characterised by top-down policies and bottom-up initiatives implemented by democratic governments.<ref name=":2"/> Top-down policies are planned and implemented by formal leaders in an organisation, while bottom-up policies involve gradual change initiated and sustained by lower-level members of organisations.<ref>Template:Cite journal</ref> Policies implemented are designed to incentivise public and private sector innovation.<ref name=":2"/> Examples include strong research and development funding, and policies which protect intellectual property rights.<ref name=":2"/>

Competition law

Template:See also Template:Further A characteristic of democratic capitalist economies is the democratic enactment of laws and regulations to support competition. Such laws include United States antitrust laws.<ref name=":1"/> Competition laws are designed to regulate private sector activities, including the actions of capital asset owners and managers, in order to prevent outcomes which are socially undesirable according to the democratic majority.<ref name=":1"/>

The implementation of competition law is intended to prevent anti-competitive behaviour that is harmful to the welfare of consumers, while maintaining a free market economy.<ref name=":1"/> The implementation of antitrust laws was found to be a characteristic of democratic capitalism specifically, and not regular free-market capitalism.<ref name=":1"/>

Conflicts between notions of resource allocation

According to economic sociologist Wolfgang Streeck, the capitalist markets and democratic policies that characterise democratic capitalism are inherently conflicting.<ref name=":0"/> Streeck suggests that under democratic capitalism, governments tend to neglect policies of resource allocation by marginal productivity in favour of those of resource allocation by social entitlement, or vice versa.<ref name=":0"/> In particular, he comments that the accelerating inflation of the 1970s in the Western world can be attributed to rising trade-union wage pressure in labour markets and the political priority of full employment, both of which are synonymous with democratic capitalism.<ref name=":0"/>

In Catholic social teaching

Catholic texts offer support for a form of socially regulated democratic capitalism.<ref name=":12">Template:Cite journal</ref> The papal encyclical Centesimus annus, written by Pope John Paul II, emphasizes a vision of a communitarian form of democratic capitalism.<ref name=":12"/> The communitarian system of democratic capitalism described promotes respect for individual rights and basic workers’ rights, a virtuous community, and a limited role for the state and the market.<ref name=":12"/> According to the encyclical, these characteristics should be combined with a conscious effort to promote institutions which develop character in individuals.<ref name=":12"/> The encyclical stressed to decision makers the importance of the dignity of the person and a concern for the poor, while acknowledging the need to balance economic efficiency with social equity.<ref name=":12"/> The US Bishops’ 1986 Pastoral Letter Economic Justice for All suggested that specific institutional arrangements be developed to support this form of democratic capitalism.<ref name=":12"/> Arrangements proposed included structures of accountability designed to involve all stakeholders, such as employees, customers, local communities, and wider society, in the corporate decision making process, as opposed to stockholders only.<ref name=":12"/> The letter offered acceptance for the market economy under the condition that the state intervene where necessary to preserve human dignity.<ref name=":12"/>

See also

• Democratic communism
• Democratic socialism
• Georgism
• Libertarian paternalism
• Mixed economy
• Neoclassical liberalism
• Post-war consensus
• Regulatory capitalism
• Social democracy
• Social market economy
• State capitalism
• Welfare capitalism