James Hamilton, 3rd Earl of Arran

James Hamilton, 3rd Earl of Arran (1537–1609) was a Scottish nobleman and soldier who opposed the French-dominated regency during the Scottish Reformation. He was the eldest son of James Hamilton, Duke of Châtellerault, sometime regent of Scotland. He was of royal descent, and at times was third or fourth in succession to the Scottish crown; several royal marriages were proposed for him, but he ultimately never married. He went to France with Mary, Queen of Scots, where he commanded the Scots Guards. After returning to Scotland, he became a leader of the Protestant party against Mary and her French supporters. However, he went insane in 1562 and was confined for the rest of his life.

Birth and origins

James Hamilton may have been born in 1537 or 1538,Template:Sfn<ref>Joseph Bain, Calendar State Papers Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), p. 362</ref> another source suggests a date in 1532.<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, vol. 10 (Edinburgh, 1936), p. 31, says he was 57 in 1589.</ref> His place of birth probably was Hamilton, Lanarkshire. He was the eldest son of James Hamilton and his wife Lady Margaret Douglas. His father was the 2nd Earl of Arran and was created Duke of Châtellerault in France in 1548. His father also was the grandson of Mary, eldest daughter of James II and was at this time, after King James V, the most senior, legitimate male descendant of King James II and, so heir presumptive for much of King James V's reign and the future 3rd Earl of Arran was next in succession after him. His father's family descended from Walter FitzGilbert, the founder of the House of Hamilton, who had received the barony of Cadzow from Robert the Bruce.Template:Sfn

James's, mother, Lady Margaret Douglas, was the daughter of James Douglas, 3rd Earl of Morton. She descended from James IV through an illegitimate daughter, and Joan, daughter of James I. Both parents were Scottish. They had married in September 1532.Template:Sfn

James listed among his brothers
He heads the list of his brothers as the eldest son: James (1537–1609) Gavin, died youngTemplate:Sfn John (1540–1604), became the 1st Marquess of HamiltonTemplate:Sfn David (died 1611)<ref>Chatellherault's will, NAS ECC8/8/4</ref>Template:Sfn Claud Hamilton, 1st Lord Paisley (1546–1621), from whom descend the earls, marquesses, and dukes of AbercornTemplate:Sfn

James's sisters
Barbara, married in 1553 James Fleming, 4th Lord FlemingTemplate:SfnTemplate:Sfn Jean, married Hugh Montgomerie, 3rd Earl of Eglinton in 1555Template:SfnTemplate:Sfn Anne (c. 1535 – before April 1574), married George Gordon, 5th Earl of HuntlyTemplate:Sfn Margaret, married Sir Alexander, eldest son of George Gordon, 4th Earl of HuntlyTemplate:Sfn

In 1542, James and his father were displaced in the royal succession by the birth of James V's daughter, Mary (the future Mary, Queen of Scots) - until James V died only six days later. James's father became regent for the baby queen.

Regent Arran's marriage plans

The Regent proposed various royal marriages for his son, who was second in line for the crown.

In March 1543, James V's widow, Mary of Guise told the English ambassador Ralph Sadler that the Regent "mindeth to marry" her daughter Queen Mary to his son, something she was anxious to avoid.<ref>Arthur Clifford, Sadler State Papers, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1809), p. 86.</ref> In December 1543, French envoys heard that the Regent wanted to marry James to Henry VIII of England's daughter Lady Elizabeth (later Elizabeth I).<ref>Gladys Dickinson, Two Missions of de la Brosse (Edinburgh: SHS, 1942), pp. 40–41.</ref> This may have been offered by Henry himself as a price of the Regent's allegiance, but nothing came of the proposal either. Henry wanted to marry the baby queen to his son Edward. The Regent was a Protestant, and initially supported this in public, despite widespread opposition in Scotland.<ref name="EB1911">Template:Cite EB1911</ref>

Then in 1543 the Regent became Catholic and joined the pro-French faction of Cardinal Beaton. Henry responded with the "Rough Wooing", nine years of war to make Scotland accept the English marriage. In October 1544, James was taken to St Andrews Castle, where he was Cardinal Beaton's guest and a pledge for the alliance of the Regent and the Cardinal.<ref>Hannay (1921), p.260: Accounts of the Treasurer of Scotland, vol. 8, p. 319.</ref>

The Regent still wanted to marry Mary to James. His half-brother, John, Abbot of Paisley, met with Lord Somerville and the Earl of Angus on 28 October 1545, to get their support. Somerville's son John wrote to Mary of Guise that they would not be persuaded.<ref>Annie I. Cameron, Scottish Correspondence of Mary of Lorraine (Edinburgh: SHS, 1927), pp. 147-148.</ref> Alexander Crichton of Brunstane and a diplomat in France, Johannes Sturm, also sent warnings of this marriage proposal to England. Sturm realised the marriage would hinder Anglo-French peace treaty negotiations.<ref>Letters & Papers, Henry VIII, 20:2 (London, 1907), nos. 622, 927.</ref> James remained in the Cardinal's custody. In February 1546 he was sent a book of Latin exercises and a copy of Aesop's Fables.<ref>Hannay (1921), p. 260: Accounts of the Treasurer of Scotland, vol. 8, p. 440.</ref>

In 1546, a Protestant band seized St Andrews Castle and murdered the Cardinal. James was held prisoner and hostage. The Regent besieged St Andrews; the Protestants offered to give James to Henry VIII, in return for the help of an English fleet. Henry VIII was willing, but never actually sent the fleet.<ref>State Papers Henry VIII, vol. 5 (London, 1836), 560–561, 565, 572, 576</ref> On 14 August 1546, the Parliament of Scotland excluded James from the royal succession (he was then third) for the duration of his captivity.<ref>Letters & Papers Henry VIII, 21:1, (London, 1908), no. 1456.</ref> Despite Henry's promises, the castle was finally taken with the help of French ships.<ref>Elizabeth Bonner, Elizabeth, 'The Recovery of St Andrews Castle in 1547', English Historical Review (June 1996), pp. 578–598.</ref>

Regent Arran now agreed to the marriage of Mary to the Dauphin Francis, son and heir of King Henry II of France, confirmed by the Treaty of Haddington. For arranging the marriage of Mary and Francis, the Regent was made Duke of Châtellerault, and James succeeded him as Earl of Arran. He would not inherit the French title, his father having forfeited it in 1559.<ref name="EB1911"/>

In France

Queen Mary was sent to France in August 1548. James Hamilton went with her or shortly earlier in July.<ref>Marcus Merriman, The Rough Wooings (Tuckwell, East Linton, 2000), p. 309.</ref> Though only a boy of 16 or younger, he was appointed captain of the royal Garde Écossaise (Scots Guard), and in 1557 distinguished himself in the defence of St. Quentin.<ref>Calendar State Papers Spanish, vol. 9 (London, 1912), p. 269.</ref><ref name="EB1911"/>

James was admired in France. In 1549, the Emblemata, a collection of illustrated Latin proverbs and mottos compiled by Italian jurist Andrea Alciato appeared in a new French edition.<ref>Alciati (1549), web presentation by Glasgow University, Template:Cite web</ref> The Emblemes D'Alciat was dedicated to him.<ref>Michael Bath, 'Alciato and the Earl of Arran', Emblematica. An Interdisciplinary Journal for Emblem Studies, 13 (2003), pp. 39-52.</ref> One of Arran's personal devices was a heart pierced with an arrow pointing down.<ref>Joseph Bain, Calendar State Papers Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), p. 286 no. 614</ref>

On 24 January 1553, the French royal armourer Bénédict Claye received an order for a suit of armour for James, to be delivered before 8 April 1553. The armour was decorated with engraved and gilded borders, and included a morion, a bourguignon, and accessories.<ref>Cathérine Grodecki, Documents du Minutier Central des Notaires de Paris: Histoire de l'Art au XVIe siècle, 1540-1600, 2 (Archives Nationales Paris, 1986), p. 279 no. 959.</ref>

In April 1548, Henry II offered Françoise, daughter of the Duke of Montpensier, as a bride for Arran.<ref>Marcus Merriman, The Rough Wooings (Tuckwell, 2000), pp. 301–302.</ref> Later, after Mary was betrothed to the Dauphin, a number of ladies of the court were suggested as brides for James. One was Mademoiselle de Bouillon, daughter of Henry II and his mistress Diane de Poitiers, in May 1557.<ref>A. Labanoff, Lettres de Marie Stuart, vol. 1 (London: Dolman, 1844), pp. 42–43: Retha M. Warnicke, Mary Queen of Scots (Routledge, 2006), p. 47.</ref> Others suggested brides included Claude de Rieux, Louise de Rieux (who married René, Marquis of Elbeuf), and Jeane de Savoie. But James did not marry.<ref>Durkan (1986), 159.</ref>

Queen Elizabeth

James' father gave up the Regency of Scotland in 1554, and thereafter followed a pro-English policy. It has been suggested that James was imprisoned in France as a Protestant in 1557–1558.<ref>Durkan (1986), 160.</ref> In 1558, Châtellerault proposed the marriage of James to Queen Elizabeth I of England to cement an Anglo-Scottish alliance. This proposal was supported by John Knox, the leading Protestant cleric in Scotland, and by John Jewel, Bishop of Salisbury. The marriage project gained the support of the Protestant Lords of the Congregation.<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 215, 216.</ref> Bishop Jewel remained in favour of the marriage as late as June 1560, and Elizabeth's own opinion is not known.<ref>Hastings-Robinson ed., The Zurich Letters 1558–1579 (Parker Society, Cambridge, 1842), pp. 82–83.</ref>

In 1559, Châtellerault and James openly declared themselves Protestants. James returned to Scotland escorted by English diplomat Thomas Randolph and was met by Ralph Sadler in Scotland. Both of these diplomats considered themselves his friends, and in their official correspondence during the conflicts of the Scottish Reformation, they noted signs of mental instability. On 8 December 1560, Elizabeth declared her rejection of his marriage proposal to the Scottish ambassadors William Maitland, the Earl of Morton and the Earl of Glencairn.<ref>Adams, Simon ed., Household Accounts of Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester (Cambridge, 1995), p. 146 note.</ref> A later chronicler, David Hume of Godscroft, believed the marriage proposal was "so unprobable, and such a proposition as Morton knew would not be very acceptable to her," but it was mooted by the Parliament of Scotland.<ref>David Reid, Hume of Godscroft's History of the House of Angus, vol. 1 (Edinburgh: STS, 2005), pp. 135–136.</ref><ref>Acts of the Parliaments of Scotland, vol. 2 (Edinburgh, 1814), pp. 605–606, Commission for the marriage, August 1560: HMC 11th Report & Appendix, part vi, Hamilton Manuscripts (London, 1887), p. 43.</ref>

Journey of Monsieur de Beaufort

At the end of May 1559, the English ambassador in Paris, Nicholas Throckmorton, discovered that Arran had declined an invitation to join festivities and tournaments at the French court. Throckmorton knew this was important, urged secrecy, and informed Elizabeth I.<ref>Joseph Stevenson, Calendar State Papers Foreign Elizabeth: 1558–1560 (London: Longman, 1863), p. 292 no. 789.</ref> When it became known, in June 1559, that his father had become a Protestant, James was at his father's French estates at Châtellerault in Poitou, perhaps at the Chateau de la Brelandiere, and became a fugitive from the French authorities. He claimed to be harvesting timber in his woodlands. Men from the Garde Écossaise were sent to Châtellerault to search for him.<ref>Joseph Bain, Calendar State Papers Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 223, 334: Joseph Stevenson, Calendar State Papers Foreign Elizabeth: 1558–1560 (London: Longman, 1863), pp. 327 no. 868, 330 no. 870.</ref>

James Hamilton made his way to safety in Switzerland by July, reportedly spending 15 days hiding in a wood on the way. His escape from France was masterminded by Elizabeth's counsellor William Cecil and the English ambassador in Paris, Nicolas Throckmorton.<ref>Estelle Paranque, Elizabeth I of England through Valois Eyes (Palgrave Macmillan, 2019), p. 44: Patrick Forbes, Full View, vol. 1 (London, 1740), p. 173.</ref> James Hamilton went first to Geneva, then to Zurich where he was the guest of Peter Martyr, and then to Lausanne.<ref>CSP Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), 234.</ref> Hamilton met Thomas Randolph alias Barnaby in Lausanne. They travelled incognito to England via Flanders.<ref>Jane Dawson, John Knox (Yale, 2016), p. 187.</ref> In London, he stayed at Cecil's Westminster home.<ref>Joseph Stevenson, Calendar State Papers Foreign Elizabeth, 1558–1559 (London, 1863), nos. 1274, 1290, 1293.</ref> James Hamilton had an interview with the Queen herself in the garden at Hampton Court.<ref>CSP Scotland, vol. 5 (Edinburgh, 1907), p. 375: Calendar State Papers Foreign Elizabeth, vol. 2 (London, 1865), p. 33 fn: Alexandre Teulet, Papiers, vol. 1, p. 357.</ref>

At the end of June 1559, Throckmorton wrote to Cecil describing how James had been unkindly handled in France. After James had left some of his Scots Guards had brawled with some French soldiers. One of the French commissioners charged with his arrest tried to apologise to Mary, Queen of Scots, as he was her close relation. Throckmorton heard that Mary had denounced James as an "arrant traitor," and he hoped that this news would advance pro-English policy in Scotland. Throckmorton hoped the Scottish bearer of the letter, Sandy Whytelaw, would do this, and though Whytelaw was not a friend of James's father, he would raise support for the marriage of James and Elizabeth.<ref>Joseph Stevenson, Calendar of State Papers Elizabeth: 1558-1559, vol. 1 (London, 1863), p. 340, no. 888: Patrick Forbes, A Full View of the Public Transactions of the Reign of Elizabeth, vol. 1 (London, 1740), p. 147.</ref>

Although Elizabeth was personally sympathetic to James's plight, for English policy the rescue was a step towards the objective of ending the Auld Alliance, knowing that on Arran's return his father, as "second person" of the realm of Scotland, would become leader of the Lords of the Congregation. William Cecil acknowledged Chatelherault's thanks for the rescue, writing on 24 August 1559, "this one thing I covet, to have this isle well united in concord".<ref>Patrick Forbes, Full View, vol. 1 (London, 1740), 166: CSP Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), 231, 241, no. 521: George Buchanan, trans. Aikman, History of Scotland, vol. 2 (Glasgow, 1827), pp. 414–5.</ref>

The name used by James while travelling through England was "Monsieur de Beaufort".<ref>Arthur Clifford, Sadler State Papers, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1809), pp. 422, 437, 447.</ref> His journey to Scotland was noted in the letters of Bishop Jewel to Peter Martyr and Henry Bullinger. In their correspondence, Arran was known by the codename Crito, Randolph as Pamphilus and Elizabeth as Glycerium.<ref>Hastings-Robinson ed., The Zurich Letters 1558–1579, vol. 1 (Cambridge, 1842), pp. 56–57, 79: Forbes, A Full View of the Public Transactions in the reign of Queen Elizabeth, vol. 1 (London, 1740), pp. 136, 147, 162, 166, 171, 183, 212.</ref> The English commander at Berwick, Sir James Croft was aware of the plan by 14 June,<ref>CSP Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), 215.</ref> and Ralph Sadler's servant Gregory Railton was sent to wait for James at Alnwick.<ref>Joseph Stevenson, Calendar State Papers Foreign Elizabeth, 1559–1560, (London: Longman, 1863), p. 516 no. 1290</ref>

Back in Scotland

James Hamilton and Thomas Randoplh were at Alnwick on 6 September 1559. They went first to the Berwick Castle and met the Scottish reformer, Henry Balnaves.<ref>Arthur Clifford, Sadler State Papers, vol. 1 (Edinburgh: Archibald Constable, 1809), pp. 405, 429, 435–436.</ref> After a midnight ride through the Cheviot Hills, at one or two o'clock in the morning of Sunday 10 September 1559, he arrived in Teviotdale, and was re-united with his father at Hamilton Palace.<ref>Arthur Clifford, Sadler State Papers, vol. 1 (Edinburgh: Constable, 1809), 519: Calendar STate Papers Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), p. 251</ref> His younger brother, Lord David Hamilton, was not so fortunate. David, aged 15, was arrested on 17 July 1559.<ref>G. Dynfnallt Owen, HMC Manuscripts of the Marquess of Bath, 5 (London, HMSO, 1980), p. 144.</ref> David was first imprisoned in the Château de Vincennes and transferred in March 1560 to the Château d'Amboise wrapped or "muffled" in a blanket.<ref>Calendar State Papers Foreign Elizabeth, 1559–1560 (London: Longman, 1865), 24, 437.</ref>

Lady Catherine Grey

In September 1560, Sarlabous, the French Captain of Dunbar Castle, tried to spread a rumour that Elizabeth's council had proposed an alternative marriage plan for Arran, with the English royal heiress Lady Catherine Grey, daughter of the Duchess of Suffolk.<ref>Joseph Bain, CSP Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), p. 483.</ref>

Arran was found to be enjoying the company of an Edinburgh merchant's daughter and daughter-in-law of Cuthbert Ramsay, Alison Craig or Craik.<ref>David Laing, Works of John Knox, vol. 2 (Edinburgh, 1848), p. 315.</ref><ref>Thomas Thomson, History of the Kirk of Scotland by David Calderwood, 2 (Edinburgh: Wodrow Society, 1842), p. 162.</ref> She was described by Randolph as "a good handsome wench" in December 1561, and the interference of the Earl of Bothwell, Lord John Stewart, Prior of Coldingham, and René, Marquis of Elbeuf led to an armed stand-off.<ref>CSP Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 582–583.</ref> Bothwell and Lord John Stewart may have been visiting houses in the town as part of a masque.<ref>Sarah Carpenter, 'Masking and politics: the Alison Craik incident, Edinburgh 1561', Renaissance Studies, 21:5 (November, 2007), pp. 625–636.</ref>

Valiant and Stout in the Cause

James joined the Lords of the Congregation and fought tirelessly against the French and Mary of Guise in the cause of the Scottish Reformation.<ref>Arthur Clifford, Sadler State Papers, vol. 1 (Edinburgh: Constable, 1809), 447</ref> With his cousin, Robert, Master of Maxwell, on his father's orders, he attacked Crichton Castle the home of the Earl of Bothwell, on 10 October 1559 James and his friends took money and silverware from Daldowie and on 9 November 1559 raided the Palace of the Bishop of Dunblane, taking a gold necklace belonging to Janet, Lady Fleming, and removing the Bishop and his silver to Stirling Castle and Falkland Palace.<ref>G. Dickinson,'Report of De La Brosse and D'Oysel',Miscellany of the Scottish History Society, 9 (Edinburgh, 1958), 95: HMC 11th Report & Appendix part VI, Hamilton Manuscripts (London, 1887), p. 223: CSP Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), 262</ref><ref>Alexander Laing, "An incident in the reformation", Proceedings Society Antiquaries Scotland, vol. 11 (1874–76), 517–525,</ref> The sixty-year-old Bishop was then imprisoned at Castle Campbell until Christmas and forced to pay for his lodging.<ref>Gladys Dickinson, 'Report of De La Brosse and D'Oysel', Miscellany of the Scottish History Society, IX (Edinburgh, 1958), p. 103.</ref> In January 1560 Arran was leading the war in Fife, writing reports to Ralph Sadler and Sir James Croft from Dysart, Wemyss, Cupar and Aberdour.<ref>Joseph Bain, Calendar State Papers Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), p. 281.</ref>

The French ambassador in England, Gilles de Noailles, reported that the Scottish rebels had told Queen Elizabeth that if they were victorious Arran would become King of Scotland by consent of Scottish lords with England as its superior kingdom. Scotland would pay England an annual fee and Elizabeth would add the arms of Scotland to her heraldry.<ref>Calendar State Papers Foreign Elizabeth, vol. 2 (London, 1865), p. 251: Teulet, Papiers, vol. 1, 396.</ref> A later English document of 1583 represents the possibility that the Scottish nobility were intent on making Arran King of Scotland, because of their dissatisfaction with Mary and her French links. The nobles were "fullie resolved to have deprived her of her government, and established the same in the eldest sonne of the Duke of Chatteleroy, the Erle of Arreyne, beinge then a gent of verie great hope and towardnes".<ref>Conyers Read, Bardon Papers (London: Camden Society, 1909), p. 13]</ref>

In January 1560, at the request of Scottish Protestants, Elizabeth sent a fleet to Scotland under the command of William Wynter.<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 287, 293.</ref> It consisted of 17 large ships belonging to the Queen, carrying a total of 3,000 men; part of the fleet was tasked with intercepting supplies from France to starve French troops in Scotland.<ref>Calendar of State Papers, Foreign, 1559-1560 (London: Longman, 1865), p. 209.</ref> At the end of January, Arran conferred with the English Admiral William Wynter at Burntisland, saying he was about to return to his father's lands in the West. By 4 February 1560, Fife was won over to the Congregation and pacified.<ref>CSP Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), 286, 287, 288, 300, 304, 308, 310.</ref> Later in February, Thomas Randolph posed as a Scot to gain the confidence of a French agent at Dumbarton Castle but Arran clumsily revealed his identity.<ref>Calendar State Papers Foreign Elizabeth, 1559–1560 (London, 1865), 399–400.</ref>

The centre of the conflict in Scotland moved to the Siege of Leith. An English army came to the rebels' support, arranged by the elder Arran in the Treaty of Berwick (1560). Before the English army arrived, the French raided Glasgow and attacked the Bishop's Palace, Arran shadowed their return to Leith with 800 horse.<ref>Thomas McCrie, Life of John Knox, 2 (Edinburgh, 1814), 410–412, Appendix no. 18.</ref> He then joined the besiegers in the camp at Restalrig. On 4 March he met the Earl of Huntly, who seemed likely to join the Congregation, at Perth.<ref>Arthur Clifford, Sadler State Papers, 1 (Edinburgh, 1809), 709.</ref> He retired from the camp at Leith by 10 April, "evil at ease," to rest at Holyrood. Within a week, Arran was in control of Blackness Castle, and returned to Edinburgh for the peace negotiations after the death of Mary of Guise in June, which led to the Treaty of Edinburgh.<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 349, 355, 357, 364.</ref> After the Protestant religion was established by the Reformation Parliament, he went with Lord James to Dalhousie Castle and burnt church books and vestments.<ref>Robert Keith, History of Scotland, 3 (Edinburgh, 1850), 7–8</ref>

Mary again

Following the death of Mary's husband Francis II of France in 1560, and the apparent failure of his English marriage plan of August 1560,<ref>CSP Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), 476.</ref> James's father again tried to marry his son to MaryTemplate:Citation needed, as first suggested in their infancy. Mary resisted such efforts.

Mary returned to Scotland in August 1561. James was chosen a member of her council on her arrival, but took up a hostile attitude to the court in consequence of the practice of the Roman Catholic religion.<ref name="EB1911"/> George Buchanan, who was unsympathetic to Mary, suggested that in November 1561, she exploited young Arran's real affection for her by spreading a rumour that he planned to abduct her from Holyrood Palace to his residence, Kinneil House, to justify strengthening the royal bodyguard.<ref>James Aikman, James, History of Scotland by George Buchanan, 2 (Glasgow, 1827), pp. 450–451.</ref> Though James' father disputed the rumour, and Thomas Randolph's considering with this "great horlyburly without reason" the Queen "had never less occasion to fear, with so many papists then in the town", physical security was tightened at Holyrood.<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), p. 574.</ref>

On 17 January 1562 Arran rode from Kinneil to Linlithgow Palace to meet with Mary, Queen of Scots, and discuss how he and his father might be remunerated for their services. The queen's half-brother, James Stewart, now Earl of Mar, married Agnes Keith on 8 February 1562. Arran escorted Mary to the feasts on Shrove Tuesday at Holyrood Palace, but became ill before the triumphs or masques on the following days.<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 597, 603.</ref> A few days later it was said that Arran had spoken "irreverently" of Elizabeth, the "Queen's Majesty", and Randolph offered his opinion to the Duke that Arran had a high opinion of his own achievements, but a tendency to fail to reciprocate well-wishers, and ought to have thanked those who favoured his suite of marriage to Elizabeth. Randolph found this flaw in his behaviour "strange". Arran now wondered if he had been better off in France serving in the Royal Guard, and spent eight days in bed in Edinburgh, tormented in his imaginations.<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 605-6, 609.</ref>

On 28 February 1562, fearing for Arran's mental health, Randolph wrote that he "is so drowned in dreams, and so feed himself with fantasies, that either men fear that he will fall into some dangerous and incurable sickness, or play one day some mad part that will bring himself to mischief".<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), p. 603.</ref>

Alison Craik

Arran had a mistress in Edinburgh, Alison Craik, who stayed in the house of a merchant Cuthbert Ramsay on the High Street. Bothwell, John Stewart, Commendator of Coldingham, and the Marquis of Elbeuf, visited the house and on a subsequent evening, after they were refused entry, they broke into the house to annoy Arran. Despite Mary's intervention, the dispute escalated into threats of violence between the Hamilton retainers and Bothwell's men.<ref>Antonia Fraser, Mary Queen of Scots (Phoenix, 2002), pp. 211–212: David Laing, Works of John Knox, vol. 2 (Edinburgh, 1848), p. 315: David Hay Fleming, Mary Queen of Scots (London, 1897), pp. 270-1 fn. 65.</ref>

The visitors were wearing masks, and the incident seems comparable to the practice of visiting in disguise in Italy, described as "brave maskerye" by the Elizabethan writer Thomas Hoby.<ref>Sarah Carpenter, "Masking and politics: the Alison Craik incident, Edinburgh 1561", Renaissance Studies, 21:5 (November, 2007), pp. 625-636: Janette Dillon, "Shakespeare and the Mask", Shakespeare Survey, 60 (2007), p. 62: Edgar Powell, "Thomas Hoby", Camden Miscellany, 10 (London: RHS, 1902), p. 14.</ref>

Allegations of a conspiracy

The strain of all this activity caused a mental breakdown. At Easter 1562, his father confined him to his bedchamber at Kinneil House. Arran escaped using a rope made from his bedsheets, and made his way across the Forth to Hallyards Castle and then to Falkland Palace. He accused his enemy the Earl of Bothwell of conspiring to abduct Queen Mary and the Earl of Moray from the deer park at Falkland, and spoke strangely of witches and devils, and "fearing that all men round about came to kill him". He said that Margaret Erskine, mother of the queen's half-brother Lord James Stewart was a witch. He was judged insane and confined for the rest of his life.<ref>Joseph Bain, Calendar State Papers Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 614–615.</ref>

George Buchanan thought the abduction plot was real and Arran a hero who tried to avoid implicating his father in the conspiracy. Arran was imprisoned first at St Andrews Castle, then at Edinburgh Castle where Bothwell was also held.<ref>James Aikman, History of Scotland by George Buchanan, 2 (Glasgow, 1827), pp. 453–456.</ref> James Stewart of Cardonald was his keeper.<ref>Thomas Thomson, History of the Kirk of Scotland by David Calderwood, 2 (Edinburgh: Wodrow Society, 1842), p. 177.</ref> Randolph wrote to Arran's old ally Throckmorton that the Earls had fallen into a "cesspit of their own making."<ref>Joseph Bain, Calendar State Papers Scotland, 1 (Edinburgh, 1898), 616, "inciderunt in foveam quam fecerunt".</ref> The Duke was forced to resign the keeping of Dumbarton Castle.<ref>David Hay Fleming, Mary Queen of Scots (London, 1897), p. 272 fn. 67.</ref>

Long twilight

Arran's expenses as a prisoner at Edinburgh Castle, where he was kept by the Earl of Mar, were paid by Mary, Queen of Scots, from her income known as the "Thirds of Benefices". The cost was 40 shillings daily amounting to £732 Scots for a year. An account of his household expenses was kept by two of Mar's servants, the chaplain Andrew Hagy and Jerome Bowie.<ref>Gordon Donaldson, Accounts of the Thirds of Benefices (Edinburgh: SHS, 1949), pp. 175-6.</ref> Randolph described Arran in a letter to Cecil in January 1564, saying he inclined to solitariness, in dark rooms, with little company or talk, and was suspicious of all he met. He was also troubled with jaundice. He ate little, and spent most of his time in bed, without getting sound sleep. His father came to Edinburgh in January 1565 to ask Mary for his release. She visited Arran in the castle and kissed him, but he spoke few words as an apology to ask for forgiveness, and remained a prisoner.<ref>Joseph Bain, Calendar State Papers Scotland, 2 (Edinburgh, 1900), pp. 34-5 no. 46, 116 no. 137.</ref> Arran was released in April 1566 and went to Hamilton, sick and without the power of speech.<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, 2 (Edinburgh, 1900), p. 277: Marguerite Wood, "The Imprisonment of the Earl of Arran", Scottish Historical Review, 24:94 (January, 1927), pp. 116–122.</ref> He was to remain within four miles of Hamilton Castle.<ref>John Hill Burton, Register of the Privy Council of Scotland: 1545-1569, vol. 1 (Edinburgh, 1877), pp. 452-4.</ref>

File:Craignethan Castle 20080505.jpg

James Hamilton was kept at Craignethan Castle by his brother John, Lord Hamilton

His father died at Hamilton on 22 January 1575.Template:Sfn He inherited his father's estate, but because of his insanity, he was placed under the care of his brother John.Template:Sfn John and his other brother Claude, Abbot of Paisley kept Arran prisoner at Craignethan Castle, and though Henry Killigrew reported in August 1575 that if he were well-used and at liberty there was hope of recovery, he was never again allowed any freedom.<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, 5 (Edinburgh, 1907), p. 179 no. 187.</ref>

His mother, Margaret Douglas, and aunts Elizabeth Douglas (the wife of Regent Morton) and Janet or Beatrix Douglas wife of Lord Maxwell, his sister Anne (mother of the Earl of Huntly), and youngest brother David were all also affected by mental ill-health. Thomas Randolph wrote that Arran "has twice before been in the same case," and his mother and aunts were "certain times or the most part of the year distempered with an unquiet humour."Template:Sfn<ref>Calendar State Papers Scotland, 10 (Edinburgh, 1936), p. 31.</ref> Randolph's description of Arran's symptoms sound akin to modern diagnoses of mania and bipolar disorder although details of his psychological condition will remain unknown.

John and Claud were supporters of Mary Queen of Scots, and so in May 1579 the former Regent Morton seized Hamilton and Craignethan on the pretence of rescuing James from his imprisonment.Template:Sfn John and Claud fled to England, but Arran, his mother, and Lord David were taken to Linlithgow, and his estates were taken over by the government.<ref>CSP Scotland, vol. 5 (Edinburgh,1907), p. 338.</ref> In 1581 his Earldom was given to James Stewart (died 1595),<ref>Steven J. Reid, The Early Life of James VI, A Long Apprenticeship (Edinburgh: John Donald, 2023), p. 158.</ref> but restored in 1585 along with his estates. Little is recorded of James in these later years: he died in 1609.<ref>John Durkan, "James, Third Earl of Arran, the Hidden Years", Scottish Historical Review, Vol. LXV, 2, no. 180 (October 1986).</ref> and, as he was unmarried, his title passed to his nephew James, 2nd marquess.Template:Sfn<ref name="EB1911"/>

Timeline
Age	Date	Event
0	1537	Born, probably in Hamilton, Lanarkshire, Scotland.
Template:Age	1542, 14 Dec	Accession of Mary, Queen of Scots, succeeding King James VTemplate:Sfn
Template:Age	1548, Aug	Sent with Queen Mary to France.
Template:Age	1562	Pronounced insane
Template:Age	1567, 24 Jul	Coronation of James VI, as successor to Mary, Queen of Scots
Template:Age	1575, 22 Jan	His father died at Hamilton, and he succeeded as "3rd Earl of Arran", but as he is insane, his brother John becomes earl de facto.
Template:Age	1579	The earldom was declared forfeit and the privy council decided to arrest John and Claud Hamilton.
Template:Age	1603, 24 Mar	Accession of King James I, succeeding Queen Elizabeth ITemplate:Sfn
Template:Age	1609, Mar	Died

Notes and references

Sources

• Template:Cite book – 1547 to 1563
• Template:Cite book
• Template:Cite EB1911 – for Walter FitzGilbert
• Template:Cite book – Ab-Adam to Basing
• Template:Cite book – Scotland and Ireland
• Template:Cite encyclopedia
• Template:Cite book – (for timeline)
• Template:Cite encyclopedia
• Template:Cite encyclopedia (for Hamilton)
• Template:Cite book – Fife to Hyndford (for Duke of Hamilton)

Further reading and external links

• John Durkan, 'James, Third Earl of Arran, the Hidden Years', in Scottish Historical Review, Vol. LXV, 2, no. 180, October (1986)
• Robert Kerr Hannay, 'The Earl of Arran and Queen Mary' in Scottish Historical Review, vol. 18, Glasgow (1921), 258-276 (Internet archive)
• Hastings-Robinson, ed., Zurich Letters 1558–1579, vol. 1, Parker Society, Cambridge (1842) for 'Pamphilius', 'Crito', and 'Glycerium,' see pp. 82–83.
• Joseph Stevenson, Calendar of State Papers Elizabeth, 1558-1559, vol. 1, (London, 1863)
• Marguerite Wood, 'The Imprisonment of the Earl of Arran', Scottish Historical Review, 24:94 (January 1927), pp. 116–122.
• The Kinneil House 'Great Escape', short film by the Friends of Kinneil